Comparing the strengths and weaknesses of 23 and 24 rosters

I know that our current 53 man roster is not really truly finished. There will be some depth/fringe type players added for a while but for the most part we know what most roster spots will be in 2024.

Thought it would be interesting to compare the strengths and weaknesses of last year’s 12-5, NFC East Champ, #2 seed and early exit team to this year’s 2024 roster as it stands now.

First the depth chart for the 2023 Cowboys and what their strengths and weaknesses were: (I included some key depth players on defense)

QB Dak Prescott. LDE DeMarcus Lawrence/Dorance Armstrong

RB Tony Pollard. LDT Osa Odighizhua

WR Cedee Lamb. RDT Mazi Smith/J.Hankins

WR Michael Gallup. RDE/LB Micah Parsons

WR Brandin Cooks. MLB Damone Clark/LVE

TE Jake Ferguson. OLB Marquese Bell

LT Tyron Smith S Jayron Kearse

LG Tyler Smith. S Donovan Wilson

C Tyler Biadaz LCB Daron Bland

RG Zack Martin. RCB Stephon Gilmore

RT Terance Steele. NCB Jourdan Lewis

2023 – DEFENSE:

Strengths: Defense ranked 5th overall, great pass rush, forcing turnovers in games where we had the lead, corners in coverage​
Weaknesses: Stopping a good running game, tackling in space, holding opponents when needing a stop late.​

2023 Defensive Starters no longer here: LB LVE, DT Jonathan Hankins, DE Dorance Armstrong

2023 OFFENSE

Strengths: Offense ranked 5th overall, Dak had 36 passing TDs, 9 pics, Cedee Lamb led league in receptions, Cowboys #1 in scoring pts​
Weaknesses: Running game was 15th in yds pg, offense struggled more on the road, especially if behind.​

2023 Offensive Starters no longer here: LT Tyron Smith, RB Tony Pollard, WR Michael Gallup, C Tyler Biadaz

Here’s the 2024 projected starters and big contributors:

QB Dak Prescott. LDE DeMarcus Lawrence

RB Rico Dowdle. LDT Osa Odighizhua

WR Cedee Lamb. RDT Mazi Smith/L. Joseph/J. Phillips

WR Jalen Tolbert. RDE Marshawn Kneeland

WR Brandin Cooks. MLB Eric Kendricks

TE Jake Ferguson. OLB Micah Parsons

LT Tyler Guyton OLB Damone Clark

LG Tyler Smith. S Donovan Wilson

C Cooper Bebee S Malik Hooker

RG Zack Martin. RCB Trevon Diggs

RT Terance Steele. LCB Caelon Carson

2024 DEFENSE: (on paper)

Strengths: Any D that has Micah Parsons, DLaw, and Trevon Diggs has a head start.​
Weaknesses: Pass rush looks light, Parsons may be doubled, can they stop the run? Hurts to have Bland miss 6-8 weeks.​
New starters on defense: LB Eric Kendricks, DE Marshawn Kneeland, CB Caelon Carson​

2024 OFFENSE

Strengths: Dak is a solid QB, Lamb is a big weapon, TE Ferguson is a young star and young OL may get better as season goes on.​
Weaknesses: Can we run the ball and protect the QB with two OL rookies this year? Weakness at RB makes running game a problem.​

2024 New Starters offense: LT Tyler Guyton, WR Jalen Tolbert, RB Zeke Elliott or Rico D, C Cooper Bebee

Is the 2024 roster “better” than 2023? Obviously too early to tell, but on paper it is not as strong. Anytime you START 4 rookies – two each in both sides of the ball there will be growing pains. Huge question marks in the running game and the defense s’s ability to stop the run. But this is still a good if not great roster.

How do you compare the 2023 roster to this year? Better? Or not?

Discuss this on CowboysZone (51 comments)

Site Footer